Compare limited company (outside IR35), umbrella (inside IR35) and PAYE take-home from your day rate — instantly
The most tax-efficient structure for outside-IR35 contractors. The company invoices the client at your day rate. After company costs (director salary, Employer NI, accountant fees, pension), the remaining profit is taxed at Corporation Tax rates. Post-tax profit can be extracted as dividends, which are taxed at lower rates than salary and carry no National Insurance.
Director salary: £12,570 — uses the full Personal Allowance. At this salary level, the company pays Employer NI of 15% on £7,570 (the amount above the £5,000 Secondary Threshold) = £1,136/year. This is fully deductible from company profits.
An umbrella company employs you and invoices the client. It deducts Employer NI (15% on earnings above £5,000) and its weekly margin before paying you as an employee. You then pay income tax and Employee NI (8%/2%) on your employment income. No corporation tax, no dividend strategy — just PAYE.
Shown as a reference point. The same annual gross is taxed entirely as employment income — income tax at 20%/40%/45% and Employee NI at 8%/2%. No Employer NI deduction from your income (the employer pays this separately). This is the equivalent employed take-home.
| Contract value | Ltd Co outside IR35 | Umbrella inside IR35 | PAYE equivalent |
|---|---|---|---|
| £300/day × 220 days = £66,000 | ~£47,500 | ~£42,800 | ~£45,300 |
| £450/day × 220 days = £99,000 | ~£67,000 | ~£60,500 | ~£65,100 |
| £600/day × 220 days = £132,000 | ~£84,500 | ~£76,200 | ~£80,800 |
Estimates assume £1,500 accountant fee, £30/week umbrella fee, no pension. Figures are approximate.
| Software | From | Best for | |
|---|---|---|---|
| FreeAgentOften free | £19/mo or free* | Ltd company contractors | Compare → |
| CrunchIncludes accountant | £24.50/mo | Ltd company, all-in-one | Compare → |
| QuickBooksMost popular | £14/mo | Most integrations | Compare → |
*FreeAgent free with NatWest, RBS or Starling business account. We may earn a commission if you sign up — this doesn't affect our editorial independence. See full comparison →